Parenting Report

A place for parents to share stories, swap ideas, get help, or just vent

You are here

Please Stop with the Boob Milk Guilt Trip

Replies

Todd D.'s picture
Submitted by Todd D. on

I don't feel that the purpose of the article was to make people like yourself feel guilty. My wife has inverted nipples and struggled through 5 weeks of breastfeeding my daughter. She did the best she could and I think the world of her.

I think it is more aimed at the large amount of mothers who just don't want to hassle with it and prefer to take the easy route. Formula has become an easy out.

I don't think that you should or have any reason to feel guilty. You tried very hard to breastfeed, it just wasn't in the cards for you.

sarajean's picture
Submitted by sarajean on

You're probably right, but every time I read a piece like this I always end up feeling attacked, humiliated, and guilty, like a total failure. I do wish that people would consider such things when they cite these studies and benefits and acknowledge that it's simply not possible for some women.

hellenwyeth's picture

The fact of the matter is that you DID DO THE RIGHT THING for your baby. You tried to the best of your ability to breast feed your baby. I know how hard it is to try to establish good milk production when you are restricted to a cold machine every 2 hours day in and day out while your baby is attached to machines miles away from you. It's not easy and I'll tell you what, if all the mothers out there that breastfeed their babies had to do it that way, I honestly don't think nearly as many would continue.

Now on my second child, I still feel that breast is best, I have had to supplement from time to time with formula. I broke down in tears when the ped told me that she didn't think I was producing enough. My son went on formula for a week and me, back to the pump. It can really be devastating. My husband couldn't understand why I was so upset. I felt like a failure as a mother and human being and now everytime I do nurse him, it's always in the back of my head, is he getting enough, will it be just a matter of time before I completely dry up? Hang in there mama, you're not alone.

sarajean's picture
Submitted by sarajean on

Thank you Hellen, I appreciate that. I wish that more stories like yours and mine would surface; it's so often assumed that when you don't breastfeed it's because you simply choose not to--rather than that you simply physically could not do so.

hellenwyeth's picture

I was actually planning on posting about this topic. I have friends that are sisters (both are also parents) that cannot breatfeed due to genetics. I hope that any posts I have made about breastfeeding have not offended in any way. I'm pro raising awareness of the benefits and encouraging moms to only use formula as a last resort. After all, baby's gotta eat! :) 

sarajean's picture
Submitted by sarajean on

It's great to spread the word... The article I linked to, however, made it sound like women who don't breastfeed are just being lazy, or not being good mothers, etc. I hear the new healthcare bill is requiring milk pumping rooms other than unsanitary bathrooms for mothers--maybe that will help, too. It's about time that was encouraged! I always liked how baby stores have nursing corners. It would be nice to ensure that kind of friendliness and acceptance, too. Both sides of the coin!

hellenwyeth's picture

One of my favorite places to take my kids is the Children's Museum and they stress the fact that they are breastfeeding friendly. The whole place is littered with comfy places to sit that are strictly reserved for nursing mothers. It's great not being shoved off into some corner to nurse my son, forcing my daughter's fun to come to a screaching hault. I think there should be nursing stations like these everywhere. I refuse to nurse in the restrooms. I don't even like "using" public restrooms, let alone feed my baby in there!

What I find to be a problem for women is you're damned if you do and damned if you don't. When you breastfeed, you're praised. On the flip side, expose your breast once in public, even on accident, and you're repulsive. Don't breastfeed and you're looked down at by everyone. Bottle feed in public and everyone is all smiles and doting. Too many mixed messages.

sarajean's picture
Submitted by sarajean on

You're absolutely right on the damned if you do, damned if you don't philosophy! I've read a lot of pieces about women being shunned in public for breastfeeding, too. Wouldn't it be nice if people could just stop judging one another on their parenting, period? 

Leave a Reply

Filtered HTML

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <ul> <ol> <li> <i> <b> <img> <table> <tr> <td> <th> <div> <strong> <p> <br> <u>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.